| Name | NBC Team | Last MLB Team | Last MLB Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| P.J. Conlon | Santa Barbara Foresters | New York Mets | 2018 |
| Pat Clements | Humboldt Crabs | Baltimore Orioles | 1992 |
| Pat Jacquez | Boulder Collegians | Chicago White Sox | 1971 |
| Pat Scantlebury | IN | Cincinnati Reds | 1956 |
| Pat Venditte | Derby Twins | Miami Marlins | 2015 |
| Pat Venditte | Miami Marlins | 2020 | |
| Paul Assenmacher | Grand Rapids, MI | Cleveland Indians | 1999 |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Anchorage Bucs | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| Paul Hartzell | Boulder Collegians | Milwaukee Brewers | 1984 |
| Paul Janish | Kenai Peninsula Oilers | Baltimore Orioles | 2017 |
| Paul Moskau | Tucson, AZ | Chicago Cubs | 1983 |
| Paul Powell | Wichita, KS | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1975 |
| Paul Zuvella | Matsu Miners | Kansas City Royals | 1991 |
| Pedro Borbon Jr. | Waco, TX | St. Louis Cardinals | 2003 |
| Pete Broberg | Fairbanks Goldpanners | Oakland Athletics | 1978 |
| Pete Burnside | Ft. Leonard Wood, MO | Washington Senators | 1963 |
| Pete Incaviglia | Hutchinson, KS | Houston Astros | 1998 |
| Pete Kozma | Sooner Athletic League | Oakland Athletics | 2021 |
| Pete Kozma | OK | Detroit Tigers | 2018 |
| Pete Ladd | Hutchinson, KS | Seattle Mariners | 1986 |
| Pete Redfern | Fairbanks Goldpanners | Minnesota Twins | 1982 |
| Phil Garner | Liberal Bee Jays | San Francisco Giants | 1988 |
| Phil Ortega | Casa Grande, AZ | California Angels | 1969 |
| Phil Plantier | IA | St. Louis Cardinals | 1997 |
| Phil Stephenson | Fairbanks Goldpanners | San Diego Padres | 1992 |