| Year | MVP | NBC Team |
| 2021 | Justin Eckhardt | Santa Barbara Foresters |
| 2020 | Sean Johnson | Santa Barbara Foresters |
| 2019 | Henry Cheney | Seattle (WA) Studs |
| 2018 | Patrick Mathis | Santa Barbara Foresters |
| 2017 | Ryan Langerhans | Kansas Stars |
| 2016 | Jacob Patterson | Santa Barbara (CA) Foresters |
| 2015 | Connor Savage | Seattle (WA) Studs |
| 2014 | Jon Duplantier | Santa Barbara (CA) Foresters |
| 2013 | David Benson | Seattle (WA) Studs |
| 2012 | Zach Fish | Santa Barbara (CA) Foresters |
| 2011 | Mitch Mormann | Santa Barbara (CA) Foresters |
| 2010 | Paul Gonzalez | Liberal (KS) Bee Jays |
| 2009 | Jake Sabol | El Dorado (KS) Broncos |
| 2008 | Kevin Keyes | Santa Barbara (CA) Foresters |
| 2007 | Brad Arnett | Havasu (AZ) Heat |
| 2006 | Jon Qualls | Derby (KS) Twins |
| Matt Whitaker | Derby (KS) Twins | |
| 2005 | Ryan Annetsberger | Prairie Gravel (IL) |
| 2004 | Scott Simon | Mat-Su (AK) Miners |
| 2003 | Chang-Wei Tu | Chinese Taipei |
| 2002 | Blake Gill | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 2001 | Jeff Francis | Anchorage (AK) Glacier Pilots |
| 2000 | Cory Metzler | Liberal (KS) Bee Jays |
| 1999 | Marco Cunningham | Dallas (TX) Phillies |
| 1998 | Jason Aspito | El Dorado (KS) Broncos |
| 1997 | Jeff Juarez | Nevada (MO) Griffons |
| 1996 | Kevin Frederick | El Dorado (KS) Broncos |
| 1995 | Lance Berkman | Hays (KS) Larks |
| 1994 | Jesse Zepeda | Kenai (AK) Peninsula Oilers |
| 1993 | Jeff Poor | Kenai (AK) Peninsula Oilers |
| 1992 | Mike Kane | Milothian (IL) White Sox |
| 1991 | Chris Hmielewski | Kenai (AK) Peninsula Oilers |
| 1990 | Kirk Vucsko | Milothian (IL) White Sox |
| 1989 | Jim Huslig | El Dorado (KS) Broncos |
| 1988 | Dave Wong | Everett (WA) Merchants |
| 1987 | Ken Kremer | Mat-Su (AK) Miners |
| 1986 | Steve Bales | Anchorage (AK) Glacier Pilots |
| 1985 | Kerry Richardson | Liberal (KS) Bee Jays |
| 1984 | Bill Bates | Grand Rapids (MI) Sullivans |
| 1983 | Curtis Morgan | Grand Rapids (MI) Sullivans |
| 1982 | Dave Hengle | Santa Maria (CA) Indians |
| 1981 | Keith Mucha | Clarinda (IA) A’s |
| 1980 | Kevin McReynolds | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1979 | Gary D’Onofrio | Liberal (KS) Bee Jays |
| 1978 | Bob Ferris | Boulder (CO) Collegians |
| 1977 | Bob Skube | Kenai (AK) Peninsula Oilers |
| 1976 | Greg Harris | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1975 | Mike Colbern | Boulder (CO) Collegians |
| 1974 | Steve Kemp | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1973 | Lee Iorg | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1972 | Kerry Dineen | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1971 | Bruce Bochte | Anchorage (AK) Glacier Pilots |
| 1970 | Al Gerhardt | Grand Rapids (MI) Sullivans |
| 1969 | Chris Chambliss | Anchorage (AK) Glacier Pilots |
| 1968 | Joe Tanner | Jackson (MS) Braves |
| 1967 | Frank Duffy | Boulder (CO) Collegians |
| 1966 | Ray Henningsen | Boulder (CO) Collegians |
| 1965 | Bob Boyd | Rapid Transit Dreamliners (KS) |
| 1964 | Dick Sanders | Wichita (KS) Service Auto Glass |
| 1963 | Sam Suplizio | Fairbanks (AK) Goldpanners |
| 1962 | Rocky Krsnich | Wichita (KS) Rapid Transit |
| 1961 | Al Ware | Grand Rapids (MI) Sullivans |
| 1960 | Bob Seltzer | Tampa Gibsonton (FL) |
| 1959 | Clyde Girrens | Wichita (KS) Weller |
| 1958 | Jim O’Rourke | Drain (OR) Black Sox |
| 1957 | Wilmer Fields | Ft. Wayne (IN) Dairymen |
| 1956 | Clyde McCullough | Alpine (TX) Cowboys |
| 1955 | Daryl Spencer | Wichita (KS) Boeing Bombers |
| 1954 | Donnie Lee | Casa Grande (AZ) Cotton Kings |
| 1953 | Robert McKee | Ft. Leonard Wood (MO) Hilltoppers |
| 1952 | Danny O’Connell | Ft. Meyer (VA) Colonials |
| 1951 | Steve Rapech | Sinton (TX) Plymouth Oilers |
| 1950 | Pat Scantlebury | Ft. Wayne (IN) Capeharts |
| 1949 | Bill Ricks | Ft. Wayne (IN) G-E Club |
| 1948 | Veo Story | Chatham (NC) Blanketeers |
| 1947 | Bruno Konopka | Golden (CO) Coors |
| 1946 | Les Lollis | Carmichael (CA) Firemen |
| 1945 | Cot Deal | Enid AFB (OK) Enidairs |
| 1944 | Cot Deal | Enid AFB (OK) Enidairs |
| 1943 | George Archie | Ft. Riley (KS) CRTC |
| 1942 | Ed Borom | Wichita (KS) Boeing Bombers |
| 1941 | Red Barkley | Enid (OK) Champlins |
| 1940 | Vance Cauble | Enid (OK) Champlins |
| 1939 | Roy Helser | Silverton (OR) Red Sox |
| 1938 | Andy Johnson | Buford (GA) Bona Allens |
| 1937 | Claude Gilchrist | Enid (OK) Eason Oilers |
| 1936 | Harry White | Duncan (OK) Haliburtons |
| 1935 | Satchel Paige | Bismarck (ND) Corwin-Churchills |