| 2022 | CJ Cron | Colorado Rockies | Anchorage Glacier Pilots, San Luis Obispo Blues | 1B |
| 2021 | Jeff McNeil | New York Mets | Santa Barbara Foresters | 2B |
| 2020 | Tim Anderson | Chicago White Sox | Dodge City A’s | SS |
| 2019 | Jed Lowrie | Oakland Athletics | Peninsula Oilers | OF |
| 2018 | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | OF |
| 2017 | Danny Valencia | Oakland Athletics | Alaska Glacier Pilots | IF |
| 2016 | Ian Kinsler | Detroit Tigers | Liberal Bee Jays | IF |
| 2015 | Hunter Pence | San Francisco Giants | Liberal Bee Jays | OF |
| 2014 | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Anchorage Bucs | 1st |
| 2013 | Alex Gordon | Kansas City Royals | Beatrice Bruins | OF |
| 2012 | Michael Young | Texas Rangers | Fairbanks Goldpanners | IF |
| 2011 | Heath Bell | San Diego Padres | El Dorado Broncos, San Diego Crush | P |
| 2010 | Mark Texeira | New York Yankees | MI Battlecats | IB |
| 2009 | Tim Lincecum | San Francisco Giants | Seattle Studs | P |
| 2008 | Joba Chamberlain | Cleveland Indians | Beatrice Bruins | P |
| 2007 | Jeff Francis | Toronto Blue Jays | Anchorage Glacier Pilots, Bellingham Bells, Coquitlam Athletics, Everett Merchants | P |
| 2006 | B.J. Ryan | Toronto Blue Jays | Hays Larks | P |
| 2005 | Morgan Ensberg | Houston Astros | Santa Barbara Foresters | 3B |
| 2004 | Nate Robertson | Detroit Tigers | El Dorado Broncos | P |
| 2003 | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Hays Larks | 1B |
| 2002 | Lance Berkman | Houston Astros | Hays Larks | 1B |
| 2001 | Luis Gonzalez | Arizona Diamondbacks | North Pole Nicks | LF |
| 2000 | Eric Karros | Oakland Athletics | North Pole Nicks | 1B |
| 1999 | Trevor Hoffman | San Diego Padres | Nevada, MO | 3B |
| 1998 | Robin Ventura | Chicago White Sox | Santa Maria Indians | 3B |
| 1997 | Brett Butler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Hutchinson Broncos | CF/SS |
| 1996 | Chuck Knoblauch | Minnesota Twins | Clarinda A’s | 2B |
| 1995 | Mark Grace | Chicago Cubs | North Pole Nicks | 1B |
| 1994 | Jimmy Key | Baltimore Orioles | Kenai Peninsula Oilers | P |
| 1993 | Barry Bonds | San Francisco Giants | Hutchinson Broncos | OF |
| 1992 | Andy Benes | St. Louis Cardinals | Clarinda A’s | P |
| 1991 | Bob Welch | Oakland Athletics | Boulder Collegians | P |
| 1990 | John Olerud | Boston Red Sox | Kenai Peninsula Oilers | 1B |
| 1989 | Rafael Palmeiro | Texas Rangers | Hutchinson Broncos | OF |
| 1988 | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | 1B |
| 1987 | Joe Carter | San Francisco Giants | Boulder Collegians | OF |
| 1986 | Roger Clemens | Boston Red Sox | Hutchinson Broncos | P |
| 1985 | Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | Boulder Collegians | OF |
| 1984 | Ron Kittle | Chicago White Sox | Chicago AHEPA | LF/1B |
| 1983 | Dave Stieb | Toronto Blue Jays | Kenai Peninsula Oilers | P |
| 1982 | Steve Rogers | Montreal Expos | Fairbanks Goldpanners | P |
| 1981 | Steve Kemp | Pittsburgh Pirates | Fairbanks Goldpanners, Liberal Bee Jays | OF |
| 1980 | Bruce Bochte | Oakland Athletics | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | 1B |
| 1979 | David Winfield | San Diego Padres | Fairbanks Goldpanners | RF |
| 1978 | Ron Guidry | Atlanta Braves | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | P |
| 1977 | Chris Chambliss | New York Yankees | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | 1B |
| 1976 | Randy Jones | New York Mets | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | P |
| 1975 | Mike Hargrove | Cleveland Indians | Liberal Bee Jays | 1B |
