| Player | NBC Team | MLB Team |
| A.J. Griffin | Santa Barbara Foresters | New York Mets |
| Adam Moore | Peninsula Oilers | Texas Rangers |
| Albert Pujols | Hays Larks | Los Angeles Angels |
| Alex Gordon | Beatrice Bruins | Kansas City Royals |
| Andrew Cashner | Clarinda A’s | Baltimore Orioles |
| Andrew Vasquez | Santa Barbara Foresters | Minnesota Twins |
| Austen Williams | Santa Barbara Foresters | Washington Nationals |
| Blake Wood | Anchorage Bucs | Los Angeles Angels |
| Bryan Shaw | Palm Springs Power | Colorado Rockies |
| Bud Norris | Aloha Knights | Toronto Blue Jays |
| Chris Herrmann | Houston Apollos | Oakland Athletics |
| Chris Young | Dallas Mustangs | Los Angeles Angels |
| Conor Gillaspie | Santa Barbara Foresters | San Francisco Giants |
| Curtis Granderson | Mankato Moondogs | Miami Marlins |
| Daniel Descalso | Clarinda A’s | Chicago Cubs |
| David Phelps | Peninsula Oilers | Toronto Blue Jays |
| Doug Bernier | San Luis Obispo Blues | Texas Rangers |
| Garrett Richards | Mat-Su Miners | San Diego Padres |
| George Kontos | Prairie Gravel | Chicago Cubs |
| Hunter Pence | Liberal Bee Jays | Texas Rangers |
| Ian Kinsler | Liberal Bee Jays | San Diego Padres |
| Jacoby Ellsbury | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | New York Yankees |
| James Shields | Santa Barbara Foresters | Chicago White Sox |
| Jason Castro | Anchorage Bucs | Minnesota Twins |
| Jed Lowrie | Peninsula Oilers | New York Mets |
| Jeff McNeil | Santa Barbara Foresters | New York Mets |
| Jesse Chavez | Anchorage Glacier Pilots | Texas Rangers |
| Josh Harrison | Cincinnati Steam | Detroit Tigers |
| Justin Wilson | Santa Barbara Foresters | New York Mets |
| Ken Giles | Casa Grande Cotton Kings | Toronto Blue Jays |
| Kurt Suzuki | Anchorage Bucs | Washington Nationals |
| Marc Rzepczynski | Peninsula Oilers | Arizona Diamondbacks |
| Mark Melancon | Duluth Huskies | San Francisco Giants |
| Matt Albers | League City Hornets | Milwaukee Brewers |
| Nate Jones | Cincinnati Steam | Chicago White Sox |
| Pat Venditte | Derby Twins | San Francisco Giants |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Anchorage Bucs | St. Louis Cardinals |
| Pete Kozma | Sooner Athletic League | Detroit Tigers |
| Ryan O’Hearn | Santa Barbara Foresters | Kansas City Royals |
| Sergio Romo | Lake Havasu Heat | Miami Marlins |
| Tim Anderson | Dodge City A’s | Chicago White Sox |
| Tim Lincecum | Seattle Studs | Texas Rangers |
| Tony Cingrani | Clarinda A’s | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| Tyson Ross | Anchorage Bucs | Detroit Tigers |